Since the formation of the earliest human communities, it has been evolutionarily advantageous to distinguish between “us” and “them” to protect our own and remain wary of potential threats.
We see similar behavior throughout the animal kingdom, where social mammals often organize themselves into groups and defend their own against perceived outsiders.
Yet unlike other species, homo sapiens have taken this tendency far beyond its original purpose. What began as a survival mechanism has evolved into something else entirely: a relentless need to affirm our belonging to the “right” group by defining ourselves against the “wrong” one. Everyone wants to be good, and so everyone feels compelled to identify a villain.
At our best, we recognize that every human being belongs within our shared moral community.
A healthy society seeks to bring people together rather than divide them, recognizing that dignity, respect, and compassion belong to all people. Differences will always exist, but integration and mutual understanding create stronger communities than exclusion and hostility ever can.
Looking back through history, we can easily recognize the causes we now condemn. We oppose the Nazis, the witch trials, the crucifixion of Christ, wars, cults and massacres. More recently, we stand against bullying, discrimination, racism, sexism and countless other injustices.
And rightly so. Many of these movements have brought about genuine moral progress.
Societies have become fairer, more inclusive and more conscious of the suffering that prejudice, cruelty and indifference can cause.
Yet every correction carries the risk of overcorrection.
When the pursuit of justice becomes a pursuit of moral superiority, when disagreement becomes evidence of wickedness and when people are judged not by their character but by their membership in a particular group, we begin to recreate the very divisions we sought to overcome.
At the same time, we align ourselves with various causes — pro-life or pro-choice, pro-immigration or pro-border control, advocates of one vision of society or another. Whatever the cause, we choose a side, and every side comes with an opposing side.
And so we march confidently into the sunset, pleased with ourselves.
The irony, of course, is that people on both sides often think exactly the same thing.
The cycle continues. Men against women. Women against men. Adult children against the parents who supposedly gave them trauma. Liberals against conservatives. Conservatives against liberals. Everyone has a cause. And those who hesitate to choose a side are often told that neutrality itself is a moral failure — that silence is complicity, that refusing to join the battle is itself a form of wrongdoing.
Human progress often begins with a challenge to injustice. But somewhere along the way, our pursuit of justice can become a pursuit of certainty — of proving that we are the good people and that others are not.
Can we not see the absurdity of this pattern?
We say we want peace, yet our thinking is rooted in division. We say we want unity, yet we condemn one another daily. We say we want love, yet it takes remarkably little to awaken hatred, contempt, or anger within us.
Perhaps the problem is not that we care too much about justice, but that we have become addicted to moral certainty.
So perhaps today we can practice something different.
Perhaps we can try loving our “enemies,” as many of history’s greatest teachers have urged us to do for centuries. Let us show compassion not only to those we have already decided deserve it, but also to those who think differently, vote differently, believe differently or simply make us uncomfortable.
Perhaps what we need is not another slogan, another outrage, or another performance of righteousness. Perhaps what we need is the willingness to listen — to genuinely listen — and to understand. Perhaps we can begin looking for what unites us rather than what divides us.
Help keep the City Paper free.
No paywalls.
No subscription cost.
Free delivery at 800 locations.
Help support independent journalism by donating today.
