Charleston County School District board trustees on Monday afternoon swore in two new members and elected a new board chair after the results of the Nov. 3 election that broke up a conservative majority faction that has dominated board meetings and decisions.
Trustees voted 5-4 to elect Darlene Dunmeyer-Roberson, who represents District 8 in the western part of the county. She and fellow board members Carol Tempel, Craig Logan, Joy Brown and Libby Tisdale voted to approve the motion, while members Michelle Leber, Keith Grybowski, Carolina Jewett and Bethany Nemitz voted against it.
The election prompted loud applause from those in attendance. The Rev. Nelson B. Rivers III, a longtime critic of the four-year conservative majority backed by the right-wing Moms for Liberty group, said Dunmeyer-Roberson’s election was historic for the county. The first Black woman on the school board was celebrated civil rights activist Septima Clark in 1972, while the first Black woman chair was the late longtime educator Liz Alston some 30 years later, he said.
“If I had to design a great board member for the public school system, it would be Darlene,” said Rivers, who pastors Charity Missionary Baptist Church in North Charleston. “She’s educated, empathetic, articulate and well-trained because she comes out of the public school system. And she’s from the community where the school board intentionally would not serve for years — and that’s on the islands.”
Dunmeyer-Roberson recognized her opportunity to be chair represented “something greater than any one individual,” she said at the Monday meeting. “It is a reminder of the importance of representation, the responsibility of leadership and the doors that we must continue opening for those who will follow.”
Jewett, a new member who was also nominated to be chair, was voted vice-chair. Logan and Brown will lead the audit and finance committee.
Turning point
Brown, who was newly elected to represent West Ashley’s District 7, said Dunmeyer-Roberson’s election was a turning point for a school board that has grown “weak” over the last several years.
“One of the main jobs of the board is to govern through policy, and [the previous board] didn’t have a fully fleshed-out policy process,” Brown told the Charleston City Paper. “It allowed the district [staff] to write policy, and they would approve it. Right there, you’re going to lose me. That is a board responsibility.
“We have seen a lot of rubber-stamping of things and celebrations of a superintendent,” she added. “But I don’t think having a strong board and a strong superintendent have to be mutually exclusive. We can do both, and we need to do both.”
Her words echoed a strong point Dunmeyer-Roberson made after her election.
“We are a public governing body, elected by the people, accountable to the people, and entrusted to ensuring student success,” Dunmeyer-Roberson said. “Our responsibility is clear: The board governs, the superintendent administers and together we will deliver results for all children.”
In addition to returning to a stronger governing body, other board priorities include transparency and communication and community involvement, members said.
A turnabout
Dunmeyer-Roberson’s election came as a surprise to some, as it followed a state investigation into possible misconduct earlier this year that Gov. Henry McMaster requested in January.
A report by the S.C. Inspector General’s office alleged she disclosed confidential information to vendors and news outlets on at least 28 occasions. The report also raised allegations involving board policy violations, taxable income and billing related to her business.
In October, however, McMaster said he would not remove her from the board, though he claimed his decision did not “exonerate” her. He did, however, decline to remove her due to that being “a most significant action.”
Brown said that she didn’t feel as though the investigation or allegations were enough to stop her from voting in favor of Dunmeyer-Roberson as chairwoman.
“Even with the controversy, that doesn’t define who Ms. Roberson is as a person or board member,” Brown said. “I have only seen her to be professional, and I believe she is the most qualified to be board chair.”
Brown said she hoped to see Dunmeyer-Roberson lead trustees away from the faction politics and communication breakdowns that plagued the school board from 2022 onward.
Rivers added, “The people who came to help make the change were elected. They weren’t appointed. And that means that the new way of doing the business of the board is going to happen.
“Moms for Liberty came with a seek and destroy [mission]. This group wants to seek and build. They want to make sure all the children who were left out will not be left out any longer.”
Andy Brack contributed to this story.



