Strangers with Candy
Comedy Central Films
Directed by Paul Dinello
Starring Amy Sedaris, Paul Dinello, Greg Hollimon, and Stephen Colbert
Rated R

In the neverending slate of movies about obnoxiously gorgeous teenagers having ridiculous amounts of sex and, oh, making killings on the stock market or getting killed by crazed axe murderers or whatever, Strangers with Candy is so far off that adolescent scale that it exists in its own demented parallel universe. No, scratch that: There’s demented, and then there’s the plain sick and twisted tastlessness and hilarious audacity of this afterschool special gone horribly, wonderfully wrong. It’s all the awful nightmare of high school, shrink-wrapped and served back to us piping hot with snark and dripping with a secret sauce of extreme warpedness.

If you’ve seen even some of the 30 episodes that constituted the 1999–2000 Comedy Central “sitcom” of the same name, the misadventures of 46-year-old Jerri Blank — “boozer, user, and loser” — will be less of a perverse revelation than if you come to its wild absurdity fresh. A teenage runaway for 32 years, Jerri is making up for lost time by going back to high school, where no one seems to notice her advanced age but everyone can peg her exact level of uncoolness to the nanometer. Strangers with Candy the TV series gave us Jerri already in the dreadful thrall of high school interpersonal politics, desperately vying to become one of the popular kids. The movie rewinds just a bit to show Jerri’s return home — to the decades-comatose father (Dan Hedaya in the film); witchy, bitchy stepmother (Deborah Rush); and jock stepbrother (Joseph Cross), all of whom despise her with a casual passion — and her initial foray into the snakepit of cafeteria-table jockeying and science-fair machinations. But with a newly packaged box set of the complete TV series just out on DVD, those discovering this delicious oddity in either form can feast on the other. The few differences between the two incarnations aside, it’s all of a kind, and you either appreciate its uniquely off-kilter comedy or you don’t.

It all comes down to buying comedian Amy Sedaris as Jerri, whether the performer’s own deep strangeness makes you laugh or makes you uncomfortable … or if it doesn’t disturb you if she does both at the same time. Hidden under faux-fat padding and hideous makeup (electric-blue eyeshadow!), Sedaris navigates a weird realm somewhere near the intersection of pathetic, poignant, and parolee as Jerri, and her reeking desperation to be “normal” — and to let the world define for her what “normal” is — is as outrageous as it is more than a little sad. The world around Jerri — created for the TV series by Sedaris, Paul Dinello (who directs and costars here), and The Colbert Report‘s Stephen Colbert (also costarring) — is a wicked sendup of the ecosystem of high school and the particular self-centeredness of teenagers, an incisive portrait of universal, individual myopia on the part of students and teachers alike, people so consumed with their own neuroses that they might as well be living in hermetically sealed bubbles. (Ironically, though, the one can’t-miss extra on the DVD set is a startling retro public service announcement dating from the early 1970s featuring a real-life Jerri Blank imploring kids not to go down that long road of drugs and drink and mindless sex — the character sprang from one woman’s desire to share her pain and keep it from others. Here, the comedy springs from that pain, if in a twisted-in-on-itself kind of way.)

A few minor changes from the TV series reflect the changes the world has gone through in recent years, new venues ripe for satire — Colbert’s idiot history teacher in the TV series has morphed into an antiscience evangelical science teacher whose classroom blackboard features an equation that includes the acronym “WWJD.” Strangers With Candy is an aggressively subversive comedy that pushes buttons and ignores barriers.

Stay cool. Support City Paper.

City Paper has been bringing the best news, food, arts, music and event coverage to the Holy City since 1997. Support our continued efforts to highlight the best of Charleston with a one-time donation or become a member of the City Paper Club.