Greenville’s Summit took advantage of a 30-year-old law to improve affordable housing Credit: Courtesy JE Properties

It all started with a phone call from a constituent.

“There was a lady who lived on Nassau Street,” said former S.C. Rep. Jimmy Bailey of Charleston, referring to a street in the city’s historically Black Eastside neighborhood. “And the city had a great program at the time — affordable, low-income, second mortgages for home renovations. And she got it.”

Thanks to the program, he said, she was able to save her family home — and a little piece of Charleston history in the process.

“But then she called me several months later, crying,” continued Bailey, his soft Charleston accent turning hard. “Her tax bill had doubled.”

And thus was born what eventually came to be known as the Bailey Bill. Since 1992, it has given local governments the authority to freeze property taxes on historic homes for up to 20 years after major renovations. Bailey, who lives in West Ashley, represented Charleston in the state legislature from 1989 to 1994.

In the years since the bill passed, at least 19 local governments across the state have adopted the measure to preserve historic homes and buildings, according to data from the Municipal Association of South Carolina (MASC).

And in just one of those cities alone — Columbia — a 2023 independent study found the bill had preserved 210 historic properties while generating $216 million in private investment.

“For every $1 of [city] investment required through the Bailey Bill, an additional $15 was spent in qualifying rehabilitation projects,” the authors reported.

Still, in a state where housing prices have exploded in the last decade, Bailey today wonders if the other major provision of the bill — “the affordable housing piece” as he called it — got lost over the years.

That’s because the Bailey Bill doesn’t just allow local governments to freeze taxes when historic homes are saved. They can use it for affordable apartment buildings, too, he said.
“If you didn’t know what you were looking for, you might miss it,” he said. “You wouldn’t realize that it also applies to low- and moderate-income housing — but it does.”

In fact, everyone seemingly did miss it for almost 25 years, until an out-of-state developer who wanted to upgrade an Upstate senior living apartment building without turning it into expensive market-rate housing dug into the law.

More on that later.

How it works

Key to the Bailey Bill’s appeal, MASC’s Jenny Boulware told the Charleston City Paper, is its simplicity and flexibility.

Under the law, cities and counties are empowered to freeze assessed property values on historic and affordable homes for up to 20 years, but most of the details are left to local officials.

If they want to designate specific Bailey Bill zones where owners can use the tax break, they can. If they want to apply it to properties with local historic values that aren’t on the federal register, that’s up to them. And if they want to shorten the period to, say, 10 years, or lock in long-term affordability requirements, they can do that, too.

Bailey Sr. | Photo from the South Carolina legislative manual on scstatehouse.gov

“The Bailey Bill is an incredibly powerful tool for sites that might be more challenging financially,” Boulware said. “And you can see great examples of that all across the state.”

One of those examples is near the Georgia border in Beaufort, where former Mayor Billy Keyserling says the Bailey Bill was recently used to save the city’s last freedman’s cottage.

Built by an abolitionist who moved South after the Civil War, the cottage was run-down and bare bones — no bathroom, no electricity, no plumbing — but still in the hands of three elderly sisters whose ancestors bought it from the original builder.

Working with the federal government and a local nonprofit, Keyserling and the sisters were able to secure a grant to renovate the cottage. But there was still one problem.

“They would have gotten absolutely killed on the taxes,” Keyserling said.

And that’s where the flexibility of the Bailey Bill came in, allowing the city to effectively make an exception for a structure that would be open to the public — a condition of the grant — rather than used as a personal residence.

“So now, they still own the house,” Keyserling said. “And they’re able to put a little of the tax savings aside every month for maintenance.”

Affordable housing, too?

Nine years ago, Joe Eddy, president of JE Properties in Boston, was looking to purchase and renovate the Summit, downtown Greenville’s first skyscraper, which was built in 1911 as the Imperial Hotel.

What he wasn’t looking to do was throw out the 100-plus low-income senior citizens who were living in the building at the time.

“We knew Greenville was interested in preserving affordable housing,” Eddy told the City Paper. “So reading through the state laws, we came across this Bailey language, and we said, ‘Hey, this is something we should look at.’ ”

But he realized something else, too: “The issue was that no one had done it before, right?”
So Eddy and his team reached out to the city, explained the unexplored opportunity offered by the law, and worked with Greenville officials to draft an ordinance implementing the Bailey Bill locally.

“Affordable housing is one of our top priorities, if not our top priority,” Greenville council member Dorothy Dowe said. “And the developer needs to make these deals pencil out. So we were able to use the Bailey Bill to save this critical part of our affordable housing spectrum.”
Earlier this year, Eddy invested another $10 million to further upgrade the building, while the city extended his original 2018 tax break for another 20 years.

The upshot? More than 100 affordable senior housing units have been preserved through 2046.
Back in Charleston, the man who wrote the bill said he is pleased that so many cities are using it — and that the affordable housing portion was finally being rediscovered.

Still, he’s painfully aware of the irony that the only major city in the state that didn’t implement the Bailey Bill was Charleston — the one he wrote it for — mostly due to concerns over lost property taxes in already gentrifying neighborhoods.

“Had they done it, those neighborhoods I represented would still look a lot more like they did then,” Bailey said. “And that’s just a damned crying shame.”

But, he noted, there’s still time for Charleston to adopt the affordable housing side of the bill, particularly as Mayor William Cogswell looks for ways to pay for his plan to add 3,500 new, price-restricted units to the city’s housing stock by 2032.

“That ain’t gonna happen unless the private sector gets involved — and the private sector ain’t going to get involved unless it makes economic sense,” Bailey said. “The good news is the Bailey Bill can help with that.”


Help keep the City Paper free.
No paywalls.
No subscription cost.
Free delivery at 800 locations.

Help support independent journalism by donating today.

[empowerlocal_ad sponsoredarticles]