A devout but not humorless Roman Catholic author once observed that the greatest proof of the church’s divinity “might be found in the fact that no merely human institution conducted with such knavish imbecility would have lasted a fortnight.”
Modern case in point: The United States Postal Service. It has had $120 billion in losses since 2007 and has yet another round of major service cutbacks looming. And with legendarily abysmal service, breakdowns, slowness and more, it certainly seems to have “knavish imbecility” by the ton.
And for the record, yes, we’d be saying this even if a piece of return mail hadn’t arrived in our office last week … 47 months after it was sent.
Of course, defenders of the service will note — correctly — that none of this is the fault of the 600,000-or-so men and women who collect, collate and deliver almost 110 billion pieces of mail to 170 million U.S. addresses every year. There’s a reason the most popular person in so many neighborhoods is the one with a mail sack on their back.
But the hard work and dedication of the rank-and-file doesn’t get their bosses, presidential and appointed, off the hook. And it certainly doesn’t excuse the fiduciary malpractice of the people who spent the past several decades creating, and then not solving, this problem — the U.S. Congress.
How many decades? Almost six, believe it or not — going all the way back to the creation of USPS in 1970.
Up until that time, mail delivery in the U.S. was handled by the federal Post Office Department, a cabinet agency like any other since George Washington’s day. But with costs rising, Congress decided it was time to run the operation more like a business.
Enter USPS, an “executive entity” — read quasi-corporation — that was expected to operate with the revenues it generated by delivering the mail, only with unfunded mandates like six-day-a-week service to every address piled on top.
Despite that contradiction, the service managed to muddle through until 2007, when Congress saddled it with billions of dollars a year in new upfront costs for its future retiree health care. That led to chronic deficits and deferred investments in maintenance and new technology. And as the competition from email and private package delivery continued to hammer the service, the repeal of that requirement in 2022 didn’t undo the damage.
Now, as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress next year, it’s past time to give USPS the help it needs — some combination of greater autonomy, fewer mandates and more opportunities to compete, along with direct payments for the mandates that Congress wants to keep, such as rural post offices and universal service.
In other words, stop just telling the USPS to run itself like a business — and finally start paying it like one. Otherwise, expect to get returned mail four years after it was sent.



